- Defendant
-
Zeeshan Mian
(Lincoln's Inn)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Andrew Goymer (Chair)
- Ms Lakshmi Ramakrishnan
- Ms Stephanie McIntosh
- Ms Zoe Saunders
- Ms Hayley Firman
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred. Costs of £2670.00 to be paid to the Bar Standards Board.
- Status
- Appeal pending
- Date
- Thursday 16 June 2022
Findings and sanctions of past hearings
Details of published findings and sanctions imposed by Disciplinary Tribunals since BTAS started operations on 1 February 2013 are provided here. Please note that, in line with the BTAS Publication Policy, findings will be removed from the website after 2 years, unless the finding of the Disciplinary Tribunal involves a suspension or disbarment. In these cases, the finding will be posted on the BTAS website indefinitely.
Details of findings and sanctions are published in accordance with the BTAS Publication Policy: Disciplinary Tribunals and other adjudication hearings.
In exceptional circumstances, a tribunal can require the Bar Standards Board to suspend the defendant’s practising certificate from a date determined by the tribunal and which can take immediate effect (rE227 and rE228 of the Bar Standards Board Handbook). In all other instances, the sanction described in the finding sheets attached will only come into effect after the time for appeal has expired. The date is further determined either by a decision of the Treasurer of the defendant’s Inn or the disposal of the appeal should one be made. For specific detail, please refer to the Enforcement Regulations at rE239 and rE241.
Appeals against relevant decisions of Bar Disciplinary Tribunals made before 7 January 2014 were heard by the Visitors to the Inns of Court. Since that date appeals fall under the jurisdiction of the High Court (rE236). The outcome of Visitors’ Hearings (appeals) and appeals to the High Court are also listed on this section of the website.
Using the facility below you may search by: name of barrister; date; type of hearing; sentence and section of the code.
Each set of findings is accorded a status on the following basis:
Open to Appeal: The case is within the period that a barrister can appeal the finding but no appeal has been submitted.
Appeal Pending – Sanction Stayed / Appeal Pending: The barrister has submitted an appeal, which is yet to be heard and the sanction will not be implemented until after the outcome of the appeal is known. This will be the case unless the Disciplinary Tribunal has ordered that the sanction should take effect immediately.
Final – The finding has been pronounced either after the appeal period has expired or following the result of an appeal.
New findings are posted within seven days of a decision, although it can take up to 24 hours for the finding to appear on the website following its posting (or for a finding to not show on the website following its removal).
Details of all publishable findings and sanctionss imposed by Disciplinary Tribunals from 2002 to the present date can also be found on the Bar Standards Board website by clicking here.
An alternative means of dealing with professional misconduct complaints is provided by the Determination by Consent (‘DBC’) procedure. This process is where the Professional Conduct Committee exercises its power to determine the outcome of a disciplinary case with the barrister’s consent. It is designed to provide a more speedy resolution of straightforward cases without the need for a formal Disciplinary Tribunal hearing. Further information on the procedure can be accessed here.
Details of the practising status of any barrister can be found on the Bar Standards Board website, click here for further information.
- Defendant
-
Bryan McNaught
(Inner Temple)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred.
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Thursday 24 October 2013
- Defendant
-
Tammy McNally
(Middle Temple)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- Mrs Helen Carter-Shaw
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- Mr Godwin Busuttil
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred.
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Tuesday 15 July 2014
- Defendant
-
Donal McGuire
(Gray's Inn)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Stuart Sleeman (Chair)
- Ms Jennifer Jones
- Finding and sentence
- Suspended 4 months.
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Monday 14 October 2013
- Defendant
-
Donal McGuire
(Gray's Inn)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- Finding and sentence
- 2 Years Suspension
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Monday 8 June 2015
- Defendant
-
Katrina McCarthy
(Middle Temple)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour John Price (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred. Fined £2,400.
- Status
- Final
- Dates
- Thursday 14 April and Monday 16 May 2016
- The Tribunal on the 16th May is being held in the Rose Helibron Room - 10-11 South Square Gray's Inn
- Defendant
-
Damian McCarthy
(Gray's Inn)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley (Chair)
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred.
- Status
- Appeal dismissed
- Dates
- Monday 6 - Thursday 9 June 2016
- Defendant
-
Duncan Maxwell-Stewart
(Gray's Inn)
- Type of hearing
- 3 Person Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Judge Carroll (Chair)
- Ms Tracy Stephenson
- Ms Siobhan Heron
- Finding and sentence
- Suspended for 12 Months. Contribution to Costs to BSB of £600.
- Status
- Final
- Dates
- Thursday 2 and Friday 10 September 2021
- The hearing on the 10 September is starting at 4pm.
- Defendant
-
Peter Masniuk
(Inner Temple)
- Type of hearing
- 3 Person Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- Mr Jonathan Holl-Allen KC (Chair)
- Mr Geoffrey Brighton
- Miss Sadia Zouq
- Finding and sentence
- Suspended for 4 Months. Ordered to pay costs of £1,200 to the BSB within 28 days [i.e. by the 17 February 2021].
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Wednesday 20 January 2021
- Defendant
-
Isaac Marrache
(Inner Temple)
- Type of hearing
- 5 Person Disciplinary Tribunal
- Panel members
-
- His Honour Glenn Brasse (Chair)
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- His Honour Nicholas Ainley
- Finding and sentence
- Disbarred.
- Status
- Final
- Date
- Thursday 8 June 2017